New Year’s with my Buddy’s Younger Broth
This story happened on New Year’s Eve a few years ago.
As those who’ve read our other stories know, Erin is a ravenous mid-40’s ginger of 5’8”, around 120 lbs, C-cups and a wicked butt. She’s a great flirt and even better in bed.
We made it a custom to have a New Year’s party at our home every year. We do a huge bonfire, lots of drinks, food and music and invite everyone around to join us. This particular one was a good one, the weather was fantastic, clear and cold which was perfect for the big fire and everyone was enjoying lots of drinks. With the good weather and the word of our party getting around, we had lots of guests this year. One of my good friends came with his family and brought his younger brother Dave and his family with him. My friend Peter was one of my wife’s first conquests once we decided to start inviting friends into our bed. She’d had a crush on him for years and watching and filming the two of them making love that time is still one of my all-time favourite experiences in the lifestyle.
Peter is about 5 years younger than Erin, and his younger brother Dave is about another 5 years younger again. To look at Dave, you wouldn’t think him to be Peter’s younger brother. He’s much taller at around 6’3”, and stronger looking with huge wide shoulders and a beard, essentially he looks like the stereotypical axe slinging lumberjack. Erin has always thought him cute but because he’s married and never showed an interest in Erin, she never pursued him. That’s one of our rules. If the person is married and doesn’t show an interested all on their own and pursues her, we leave them be. We’re not in the business of trying to ruin marriages.
The party was hopping that night and everyone was getting pretty drunk as the night progressed. Most of those with k**s had left before or shortly after midnight that night but the real party a****ls were still at it including Dave and his wife. They’d sent their daughter home with Peter’s family already. Unfortunately with drinking also come arguments and Dave and his wife got into a dandy one. She was way too drunk after doing shooters with Erin and finally once we got her settled down she agreed to go lay down in one of our guest rooms where she passed out like a rock within minutes. By around 2 am the rest of the guests had left, leaving Dave and I. He was apologetic regarding his wife but I told him it was no big deal as alcohol can bring out the worst in us at times. He explained that they were having some big issues in their marriage and were basically just living together for their daughter at that point. It was sad to hear as you never want friends to be in that sort of situation.
Dave, Erin and I did a bit of cleaning up, tackling the worst but most folks had been good about using garbage cans and recycling bags that we’d put around the property so there wasn’t much to do. Soon Dave and I were in the kitchen bullshitting. Erin was extremely drunk and fumbling around. She went outside for some reason, dressed only in her tight fitting white t-shirt and skirt and came back in a while later saying she was freezing. Dave and I chuckled at her antics and she stumbled across the living room and laid in front of the fire on her side for some warmth. When she laid down her skirt hiked up a bit and you could see the bottom of her ass cheeks. Dave and I were still chatting as I did some dishes, then I heard Dave say “beautiful” almost under his breath. When I looked up to see what he was referring to, I saw him staring at Erin in front of the fire. I smiled and asked him “you like what you see?” Dave immediately apologized but I cut him off telling him it was fine with me if he wanted to check her out, adding “after all, she thinks you’re pretty hot.” He seemed very surprised by that, asking me how I knew that and I told him that she’d said so many times. Then, with some liquid bravery of my own flowing through my veins I told him that “she said she’d fuck you in an instant if you ever showed any interest”. Dave stood there staring at me with a look of complete disbelief on his face. I continued, “It’s true. She has the hots for you, she just never said anything because of your situation.”
Dave now replied, with a laugh of disgust, “My situation. Ya, that’s a complete fucking mess. We haven’t been together in over a year now.” His gaze now went back to Erin’s ass. This made it easy for me to make the next move. I asked Dave, “Do you want her?” There was no immediate reply, he was lost in thought, inebriation, and contemplation, and then it seemed to dawn on him as to what I was offering. He turned back to make my stare and asked, “You mean do I want Erin?” I smiled and nodded. “You serious?” he asked again. I answered, “Yes, dead serious, as long as I can watch.”
Again his eyes went to Erin, checking her out as she lay there passed out. I could see him thinking hard and really not sure so I made a suggestion, “why don’t you go over there and at least feel her out? It’s probably been a while since you’ve touched anyone, right?” He didn’t’ say a word as he put his drink down and walked over to the fire. He got to his knees behind her and placed his hand on her hip. Erin didn’t react, deep in alcohol induced sleep now. Dave looked back at me and asked “are you sure?” I smiled and replied, “Definitely. It’ll be our secret.”
Dave now slid his hand from Erin’s hip, down onto her thigh, then back up again, pulling her skirt up to reveal more of her lovely ass as he did. His hands now started moving around her body, exploring. He cupped her ass, squeezing it, then with his other hand he reached over and cupped her breast through her shirt and bra. He fondled her this way for a short time, then rolled her onto her back on the rug. He moved his hand down her thigh and inside her knee, then pulled her legs apart and slid his hand up the inside of her thigh to her panties. He started rubbing her pussy through her thin Lycra as he slid his other hand up under her shirt. As this was getting to a point where things could get messy if one of the guests came down from the guest rooms I walked over, put my hand on his shoulder and suggested “let’s pick her up and bring her into our room for some privacy.” Dave nodded in agreement. He got up and we stood Erin up. As we did, she mumbled something, but her eyes stayed closed. She was now on her feet but barely so and needed help to stand. I whispered into her ear “It’s okay baby, I’m just taking you to bed now.” She didn’t reply, and Dave bent down, hoisting Erin up over his shoulder. I took the lead, walking to our room with the lovebirds following.
Once in our room I closed the door behind us and Dave dropped Erin onto her back on our bed. He looked at me again and asked “You’re totally sure? I’ve always had the hots for her.” I nodded again and answered, “Dave, she’s yours. Do what you want with her.”
Dave’s face changed to one of pure lust. He quickly pulled all his clothing off, dropping it to the floor. He had a very fit build, not a 6 pack but the build of a hard working real man. When his pants came down (he wasn’t wearing underwear), his cock sprang free and I was impressed. It matched his physique proportionately. He was probably around 7-8” long and a decent girth. I reached onto the shelf where I keep our camcorder and started filming. Dave didn’t take notice. Now he climbed onto the bed straddling her hips, then lifted Erin’s torso off the bed and leaned her against him. He then pulled her shirt up and off and removed her bra. He sat up onto his knees and his cock was now at Erin’s face. He held her by the back of her head and clumsily pushed his cock against her face. Although Erin was passed out, she was in that drunken slumber where you can still react and once his cock met her lips she opened her mouth for him. Dave pushed his cock into her mouth, still holding her by the hair as he started to slowly fuck her mouth. He got to his feet with his knees bent and kept thrusting slowly, pulling back to her lips, and then pushing in. He was being fairly gentle and kept glancing in my direction. I’d heard from Peter years ago that Dave’s a bit of an a****l in bed and I wasn’t sure if that was just guy talk or real so I figured I’d push. “You don’t have to be gentle bud, like I said, she’s all yours. Have fun.”
Dave turned his attention back to Erin and started to thrust a bit faster. Now he was fucking her mouth. He’d pump for a few strokes, then pull back for a moment before thrusting hard into the back of her throat, making her choke. After doing this a few times she started to open her eyes a bit, but didn’t really register anything and closed them again. After a while of this he pulled his cock out of her mouth and proceeded to smack her around the face with it. Then he pushed her onto her back on the mattress. He climbed off her and undid the side of her skirt, pulling it and her panties down in one hard pull. He spread her legs wide and put his head between them and started to lick her bald pussy. He was flicking his tongue on her clit and worked a couple of his big fingers into her and she started to moan and then started to grind against him.